First Bite: Malarkey’s Herringbone Opens
“You control the heat, you don’t let the heat control you.” Herringbone‘s pony-tailed chef de cuisine Amanda Baumgarten was out of her glass-walled kitchen and sharing her Heat Manifesto.
The dining room buzzed with chill DJ tunes, young punctual waiters, and an earthy-chic crowd checking out the latest fabric restaurant from Brian Malarkey (“Top Chef” season 3) and co.
Baumgarten (“Top Chef” season 7) is in charge of the Herringbone menu. *She talked cooking technique with my table--specifically about the King Salmon, caught by Washington state’s Quileute Tribe. It was a head turner, we said. That crackly skin! The meat inside like a color swatch easing from a Monticello peach to a Bermuda pink!
“It’s too early to write a review, don’t worry,” I came clean. Herringbone had only been open for three days by then. It’s the latest in an SD-restaurant portfolio that includes Searsucker, Burlap, Gingham and Gabardine.
Located on Herschel Avenue in a freestanding, brick-and-ivory spot with little signage (look for the fish logo lined with a herringbone pattern), Herringbone’s already upping La Jolla’s hipness.
At the entrance of this seafood spot there’s an open-area lounge mashing up beach-house comfort (sofas, fireplace) with showiness (glittery bar; century-old olive trees planted among the tables and throughout the entire space). The dining room pushes the nautical theme-puffer-fish light fixtures, a curved wooden ceiling so like the inside of a great ship. There’s another glittery bar here.
And while it’s criminal for a food writer to judge a place so early, some quick Day-3-of-This-Restaurant dinner impressions:
Our table happily clucked over Baumgarten’s free-thinking ceviche presentation. A raw fish head and tail played bookends to bite-sized pink snapper pieces marinated in cilantro, lime and chilies.
We slurped a mild ‘n creamy array of Pope’s Bay and Fanny Bay oysters.
We OMGed over the hamachi. The chili-enhanced raw fish was made even more buttery with tiny, rolled up scrolls of lardo garnishing each sleek piece.
We were stumped about the vegetable on our wood-roasted pizza with pancetta, an over-easy egg, and milky Fontina cheese. It was a stellar cluster of stinging nettles! Which are like spinach but occupy a sweeter flavor zone.
And of the Snake Oil Cocktail specialty drinks, all built around fragrances and served with perfume strips, the Tokyo Love Hotel was my fave. A twist on a John Daly, it’s a housemade sweet-tea vodka with agave and fresh pressed lemon, shaken until it gets a foamy head, then finished with Snake Oil’s “Oriental” fragrance (their words!). It’s a gentle scent (ginseng, saffron, toasted rice, and golden grapefruit) and a refreshing buzzer.
We got into five other dishes, and closed with a complex array of chocolates from dessert wunder-sweetie Rachel King.
But this is not a review. This is just one novelty hound talking to another, and telling you what I saw at the new Herringbone.
Read more of Keli Dailey’s food reviews and first bites on utsandiego.com
Source: DiscoverSD
Sign up for the Pacific Insider newsletter
PACIFIC magazine delivers the latest restaurant and bar openings, festivals and top concerts, every Tuesday.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Pacific San Diego.